Men After God

From Season 3, Episode 4

What Does 'To Obey Is Better Than Sacrifice' Mean?

By Luke Sorensen · November 12, 2026

If I did some things that dishonored Monica, or treated her disrespectfully, and then brought her flowers, do you think the flowers would mean anything?

No, they don't.

And yet we make that mistake in our relationship with God. Probably sometimes with our wives too, so just be careful. We might disrespect them, not do what honors them, and then think flowers are going to make it right.

We're in November, coming up on Thanksgiving and the holidays. Things get busier, and in the process of getting busier, it seems like we come up with all these lists. Shopping lists. Christmas lists. Meal lists, dessert lists, what-you-want-on-Thanksgiving lists.

Here's my point. I believe that many times in our Christian walk, we create lists too. The things we're supposed to do. The things we're not supposed to do. The things that are required of us, if you would. And we gauge our walk with the Lord, and what we believe is the quality of our relationship with Him, by what we did or did not do.

But the question is this: did I obey?

What does "to obey is better than sacrifice" mean?

It means God would rather have our obedience than our sacrifice. Samuel said it to King Saul, after Saul had disobeyed and then tried to make it right with an offering. To sacrifice is good. God calls us to sacrifice. The issue is substituting religious sacrifice for obedience.

In 1 Samuel 15:22, Samuel said, "Hath the LORD as great delight in burnt offerings and sacrifices, as in obeying the voice of the LORD? Behold, to obey is better than sacrifice, and to hearken than the fat of rams."

God calls us to put ourselves on the altar: "I beseech you therefore, brethren, by the mercies of God, that ye present your bodies a living sacrifice, holy, acceptable unto God, which is your reasonable service" (Romans 12:1). So there is a call to sacrifice. God established it as a part of worship.

But sometimes we get so focused on the sacrifice, on what we believe we're bringing to God as a worthy sacrifice, that we miss what God has for us in the obedience.

Your relationship with God is based on your connection through Jesus Christ, our Savior. God looks at us through the blood of Jesus Christ and says, that is my son, that is my child.

And so sometimes we put this checklist up. Well, I'm right with God because I serve in the church, I showed up, I gave, I'm faithful, I look good, I dressed up. Whatever it is you think it is, you're missing the point of obedience.

What did King Saul do wrong?

Saul obeyed partway. God told him to go and completely destroy the Amalekites and everything they had. Saul went, and he did most of it, but he spared the king and kept the best of the sheep and cattle. Then he said the best was kept to sacrifice to the Lord. Partial obedience is still disobedience.

Then Samuel shows up, and he's like, what is the sound of sheep and animals that I hear? They're supposed to be dead. Samuel's like, I must be hearing things, because God said for you to destroy it, and you didn't.

And Saul starts to give this explanation: I kept the best, so that we could sacrifice them to the Lord.

At that point, God has made it very clear that He's done with Saul. Saul has disobeyed, even though he partially obeyed.

Why did Saul only partly obey?

Saul was a people pleaser, and he said so himself. When Samuel challenged him, Saul answered, "I have sinned: for I have transgressed the commandment of the LORD, and thy words: because I feared the people, and obeyed their voice" (1 Samuel 15:24). That's Saul saying, yeah, I messed up, but the people made me do it.

Saul was not unlike the rest of us. I know there are people that are more people-pleasing than others, and I would say that I'm a recovering people pleaser, minus the recovering.

It is very natural for me to look at the impression I'm trying to make with other people. So I need to very intentionally watch my motives, and why I'm doing what I'm doing. Am I doing it because God has asked me to? Or am I doing it to gain the attention of man?

Saul says it again in verse 30: "I have sinned: yet honour me now, I pray thee, before the elders of my people, and before Israel, and turn again with me, that I may worship the LORD thy God" (1 Samuel 15:30).

Watch the motive. If he had just said, I've sinned, help me get right so I can worship the Lord, that would have been fine. But that wasn't the reason he wanted to worship. He wanted the appearance. Help me look good in front of the elders of my people and Israel, so I can worship God and feel good about it.

If you're constantly trying to find ways to worship God where people can see you worship God, then it might just be a show. And that's what Saul was all about. He was all about his show.

What does it mean to hearken to God?

To hearken is to pay close attention, to give heed, to listen attentively. There are two important Hebrew words in Samuel's statement. Shama, to obey, means to listen, often with the implication of responding. Qashab, to hearken, means to lean in.

This is where I got convicted. I knew to obey is better than sacrifice. That's a little bit simpler, right? But the part about the fat of rams, what did that mean?

Start with the first word. To obey is to listen and then respond with action, in a spirit of obedience. If you have kids, you understand the difference between a child that obeys with their heart and a child that responds with a bad attitude, right? Sometimes we'll do that to God. We'll be annoyed with our children and not realize we're doing the same thing to God, because God wants us to obey with our whole heart. He wants us to obey out of love, not out of duty.

What caught me was the fat of rams. I guess I had never really tied that in before. Under Israel's sacrifice system, the fat portions were specifically reserved for the Lord. Leviticus 3:16 says, "And the priest shall burn them upon the altar: it is the food of the offering made by fire for a sweet savour: all the fat is the LORD's."

The fat of rams was a special sacrifice, reserved only for God. Not designed for the priest. Not designed for everybody else.

Guess what? To hearken is more important than that special sacrifice.

What is God asking you to obey today?

Start with what you already know. The Holy Spirit is working in all of our lives, and unless you are quenching the Spirit, He's communicating with you in a way specific and unique to you. My pastor says this all the time: when you don't know what to do, do the thing that you know to do.

For some of you, that might be obedience in serving. It might be dealing with some secret sins you're holding on to, and creating the accountability. Some of you might be withholding offerings from the Lord, and you're convicted by that. For some of you, it might be living a holy life, or stepping up in devotions and doing what it takes to lead your family. I don't know what God is calling you to do. I just know that God is calling you to do something today.

And sometimes we substitute sacrifice for obedience in our own mind. It's not like we're pulling out an altar and saying, God, I'm going to swap this out. We justify it. I'm going to go to church and attend faithfully and do what's required of me at church, instead of leading my family.

Well, no. That's not an instead-of thing. You don't get to swap out doing church for leading your family as a man after God. You're required to do both.

For me, obeying God by saying yes to certain things means I have to say no to other things. It might be no to schedules. It might be no to good things. I've recently had to say no to some ministry things at church, where I'm very involved, because the moment I say yes to something else, I have to say no to another. Otherwise I'm not making my children a priority, my wife a priority, the relationships I'm supposed to be stewarding a priority.

I'm really not comfortable saying no. But that is part of what God is asking me to do to obey.

James says, "But be ye doers of the word, and not hearers only, deceiving your own selves" (James 1:22).

Back to the flowers. I love to buy Monica flowers. I think it's awesome, and I don't do it nearly as often as I should. But if you're a man and the only time you take your wife flowers is when you messed up or forgot something, that's not a really good thing. That's training a sacrifice concept, like a gift makes up for wrongdoing. And it doesn't.

So here's the challenge: go buy your wife some flowers for no reason at all. And pick her favorite, not your favorite.

God doesn't want your flowers. God wants your obedience.

So look at your life and do an inventory with three questions.

Who am I trying to please? Am I trying to please God, or man? Or am I trying to please myself? Pleasing God or pleasing self, there are only two choices on the shelf. Most of the time, choosing God means you're not pleasing man. And if you try to please others, you're guaranteed to fail. So stop trying to please everybody. It's not going to happen.

Am I hearkening? Am I attentive and responsive to God's Word and His Spirit, or just busy doing religious things? I would say that if the devil can't own your life, he will have a great time distracting you. As long as he keeps you busy and not doing the things God wants you to do, he wins.

What is my next act of obedience? What do you already know God wants you to do? Maybe that's prayer time. Maybe that's surrender, or accountability. Maybe you need to reach out to another guy, or go pray with someone. Maybe it's an apology that needs to be made, or some forgiveness you need to do. That's part of the obedience process, because it's going to bring you closer to Him as your Father.

This is a challenge to me too. God convicted me first. To obey is better than sacrifice, and to hearken is more important than the fat of rams.

What is the Holy Spirit asking you to do today?

Hear the whole conversation
Season 3, Episode 4
Watch the episode

Questions men ask

Does God want sacrifice or obedience?

He wants your heart in both. Sacrifice was part of the worship God established, and Romans 12:1 still calls us to present our bodies as a living sacrifice. But Samuel told Saul that to obey is better than sacrifice. The trouble starts when a religious offering is used to stand in for the obedience God asked for.

What is partial obedience?

Partial obedience is doing most of what God said and keeping back the part you wanted. Saul destroyed most of the Amalekites but spared their king and the best of the livestock, then said the animals were kept for a sacrifice. Partial obedience is still disobedience, and God made it very clear He was done with Saul.

What does "hearken" mean in the Bible?

To hearken is to pay close attention, give heed, or listen attentively. In 1 Samuel 15:22 the Hebrew word is qashab, which the King James Version translates "hearken." Its partner, shama, translated "obey," means to listen with the implication of responding. As James puts it, "be ye doers of the word, and not hearers only" (James 1:22).

Can going to church make up for not leading my family?

No. You don't get to swap out going to church and doing church for leading your family as a man after God. You're required to do both. Faithful attendance, serving and giving are good things, and they still leave the job of stepping up at home and leading your family in devotions.

Is it wrong to bring my wife flowers after I mess up?

If the only time you bring your wife flowers is when you messed up or forgot something, you are training a sacrifice concept, as if a gift makes up for wrongdoing. It doesn't. If there is an apology that needs to be made, make it. Then buy her flowers for no reason at all, and pick her favorite.

Take the next step

A free challenge every month

Short emails with a verse, one thing to do, and a question.